Inverted Race Tube Assay for Circadian Clock Studies of the Neurospora Accessions.
Sohyun Park, Kwangwon Lee. Department of Plant Pathology, Cornell University, Ithaca NY 14850
Fungal Genet. Newsl. 51:12-14
Although the Neurospora crassa circadian clock has been studied for forty years, population studies of natural accessions have been limited by technical difficulties associated with the conventional race tube assay (CRTA) that is used to measure asexual development (conidiation). Due to the buildup of CO2 in the CRTA that represses banding, a mutant strain band (bd) has been utilized for increased visualization of the banding phenotype. In order to study the circadian clock in natural accessions of Neurospora multiple techniques have been explored. One such technique, the rubidium chloride-supplemented race tube assay (RRTA) has been used successfully. Here we present a new technique, the Inverted Race Tube Assay (IRTA) that is a simple modification of the CRTA. We analyzed 5 natural accessions of Neurospora using CRTA, IRTA and RRTA and discuss the advantages of the IRTA in natural variation studies in Neurospora.
N. crassa has proved to be a successful model for studying the molecular bases of circadian clocks. Significant
insights into the mechanism of the clock have been obtained in N. crassa including a) transcriptional/translational
feedback loops in the clock that opened up the conceptual foundation for our understanding of the biological clock
(Aronson et al.1994); b) the resetting mechanisms by light and temperature (Liu et al. 1998; Crosthwaite et al. 1995);
c) circadian gating of cellular activities (Heintzen et al. 2001); and d) the involvement of anti-sense RNA in the
circadian regulatory circuit (Kramer et al. 2003).
A critical step in studying the circadian clock is the ability to easily observe and measure circadian regulated
behavior. The rhythmic behavior that has been most extensively studied in N. crassa is asexual spore development
using the CRTA. A race tube is a long glass tube (28 inch long) that is bent up at both ends to hold an agar medium.
Mycelia or conidia are inoculated at one end of the race tube and the fungus grows toward the other end. To
synchronize the cells to the same time of day, the cultures are germinated in constant light for a day and then
transferred to constant darkness. Under these conditions, Neurospora initiates asexual development about every 22
hrs (Loros and Dunlap 2001). As a result of asexual development, Neurospora produces orange colored spores
creating the “banding” phenotype. This easily tractable clock phenotype has been integral in dissecting the genetic
structure of the Neurospora circadian oscillator.
All laboratory Neurospora strains used in clock studies contain the mutation band (bd) (Sargent and Woodward
1969). In the absence of the bd mutation, the rhythmic asexual development of Neurospora in a race tube is
suppressed by the accumulated CO2, a byproduct of respiration (Sargent and Kaltenborn 1972). Before the
discovery of the bd mutant, researchers relied on a device to blow fresh air into the race tube to prevent the
accumulation of CO2. However, blown air easily disperses the highly hydrophobic Neurospora spores inside the race
tube, ruining the experiment. In the bd mutant background, the rhythmic pattern of asexual development can be
visualized without the air circulation device. It was proposed that the bd mutation desensitizes the repressive role of
CO2 in rhythmic asexual development in Neurospora, although its specific role is unknown (Sargent and Kaltenborn
1972). This repressive role of CO2 has been a major obstacle in studying natural variation of the circadian clock in
wild-collected Neurospora accessions (Morgan and Feldman 1998). In addition to the adoption of blowing fresh air
into the race tube, crossing natural accessions with the bd mutant, or the rubidium chloride-supplemented race tube
assay (RRTA) (Morgan and Feldman 1998) have been suggested as methods to monitor banding in Neurospora
accessions. However, each of these solutions created additional issues. First, crossing the accessions with the bd
strain is not desirable because it does not maintain the heterogeneity of the genomic structures between accessions.
Second, the RRTA introduces another variable; the mode of rubidium chloride action is not characterized, adding an
unknown environmental factor that further complicates quantitative studies (Morgan and Feldman 1998).
With all these technical problems in mind, we developed a modified race tube assay, the Inverted Race Tube Assay
(IRTA) (Fig. 1). We reasoned that if it is truly only the CO2 trapped in the bottom of the race tube that prevents the
rhythmic asexual development , one could remove the heavy CO2 by simply inverting the race tube. 25 ml of
media (1X Vogel, L-arginine 0.17%, D-glucose 0.1%, 1.5% agar) is poured into the race tube and autoclaved (20
min. 121 ºC). As the media cools down, the media solidifies; due to the water condensation on the inside surface of
the race tube, the solid media can settle on the bottom (what used to be the top) of the race tube as the race tube is
turned upside down. The race tube is then placed on a flat surface overnight until the excess water inside the race
tube is dried.
Figure 1. Inverted race tube assay. A) A cartoon of the inverted race tube. B) design of the race tube holder. The
holder is made of stainless steel (Incodema Inc. Ithaca, NY). C) and D) shows different sides of the race tubes. For
convenience of cleaning and maintenance, we used o-rings (o-ring 2-143, Web Seal Inc. Rochester, NY) to hold the
six race tubes as shown in C and D.
Illustrated in Figure 2, the banding phenotypes in five representative accessions were compared in the three different race tube assay methods: IRTA, RRTA, and CRTA. Banding was evident in all three assays; however, the banding pattern was clearer and more robust in the IRTA compared to both the CTRA and RRTA (Fig.2). In general, the accessions grew more slowly in RRTA than in CTRA and RRTA. There were only marginal differences between growth rates between CTRA and ITRA. In the RRTA, sporadic and non-circadian asexual development obscured accurate scoring of circadian parameters, as compared to the IRTA. There is natural variation in terms of the Neurospora accessions’ ability to cope with the adverse effects of CO2 in asexual development.
Here we present data comparing the CRTA, IRTA and RRTA in assessing the circadian clock of Neurospora accessions. The IRTA increases both the percentage of banding phenotype in accessions as well as the clarity of banding as compared to either RRTA or CRTA. Furthermore, the IRTA does not require additional equipment or media modifications from the CRTA, making the results from the IRTA parallel with current and past CRTA studies. The optimized IRTA will significantly contribute to the study of circadian clock natural variation, as well as population and ecological studies in Neurospora.
Figure 2. Comparison of the three race tube assay methods.
The numbers in the left column represent the Fungal Genetics Stock Center numbers. After inoculation, the races were incubated in constant light (500 ?moles/m2/sec) and 25 ̊C for 12 hr until there was an even growing front. Then the race tubes were incubated in constant darkness for several days. We observed that the growth rate of the accessions in the RRTA was about three-fourth of that in the inverted race tube. The images of IRTA and RRTA were taken from the bottom of race
Aronson, B.D., et al., Negative feedback defining a circadian clock: autoregulation of the clock gene frequency. Science, 1994. 263: p. 1578-1584.
Liu, Y., et al., How temperature changes reset a circadian oscillator. Science, 1998. 281: p. 825-829.
Crosthwaite, S.K., J.J. Loros, and J.C. Dunlap, Light-induced resetting of a circadian clock is mediated by a rapid increase in frequency transcript. Cell, 1995. 81: p. 1003-1012.
Heintzen, C., J.J. Loros, and J.C. Dunlap, The PAS protein VIVID defines a clock-associated feedback loop that represses light input, modulates gating, and regulates clock resetting. Cell, 2001. 104: p. 453-464.
Kramer, C., et al., Role for antisense RNA in regulating circadian clock function in Neurospora crassa. Nature, 2003. 421(6926): p. 948-52.
Loros, J.J. and J.C. Dunlap, Genetic and molecular analysis of circadian rhythms in Neurospora. Annu. Rev. Physiol., 2001. 63: p. 757-794.
Sargent, M.L. and D.O. Woodward, Genetic determinants of circadian rhythmicity in Neurospora. J. Bacteriol., 1969. 97: p. 867-872.
Sargent, M.L. and S.H. Kaltenborn, Effects of medium composition and carbon dioxide on circadian conidiation in Neurospora. Plant Physiol., 1972. 50: p. 171-175.
Morgan, L.W. and J.F. Feldman, Preliminary investigation of the circadian rhythms of wild-collected Neurospora strains. Fungal Gen. Newsl., 1998. 45: p. 30-31.
Return to the FGN 51 Table of contents
Visit the FGSC homepage